|
SPEECH OF
THE Hon. WILLIAM L.
YANCEY, OF
DELIVERED
IN THE National
Democratic Convention From the Report of the “ |
|
It would be only a small stretch to say
that this is the speech that
started the Civil War.
William
L. Yancey (1814--1863) was perhaps the most prominent "fire-eater"
during the decade prior to secession. Born in South Carolina and
educated at Williams Coillege in Massachusetts, he worked as a
newspaper editor/publisher/owner at various times, owned several
plantations, and held numerous political offices.
In 1848 he brought forward the "Alabama Platform," a response to the Wilmot Proviso. Adopted at the state level, it was never endorsed by the national Democratic Party. Throughout the tumultuous 1850s he continued to press the most radical Southern positions. This speech was delivered in response to the platform controversy that was at the heart of the dissension in the 1860 Democratic Convention. Despite this speech by Yancey, the convention adopted the minority (pro-Douglas) report of the Platform Committee on April 30, and the Deep South delegations walked out of the Convention, splitting the Democratic Party. |
|
|
Gentlemen
of the Convention: This
is a very vast subject, of wide range; whether considered as policy, or
whether
considered in its constitutional light, of very vast import, when we
consider
the consequences of the result at which we may arrive.
It has long been my study to arrive at a
correct conclusion, and experience warns me, gentlemen, that justice
cannot be
done to this subject in anything like an argument that will rise above
a mere
partisan view of the question, in one hour.
I will endeavor to compress and limit my remarks within
the time. I may be able to do so, but
before I proceed
I would like to ask it of this body, whether if my argument is not
concluded
within the hour, it will be the pleasure of the Convention that I shall
stop,
or whether it will extend to me the courtesy of allowing me to finish
at least
such branch of the subject as I may be upon when my hour expires. (Loud cries of “yes, yes,” and “no, no.”) Mr. Samuels,
of Mr. Yancey. I
would most cheerfully answer if I were able. I
believe that if I were untrammeled by time
and not speaking against time, being somewhat known for condensation, I
could
finish it in an hour and a half or better.
I think that in my attempts to condense I should not be
longer. I would say to the Convention,
however, that
I would not trespass upon its courtesy if there was a single dissenting
voice,
for I know the value of your time. (Loud
cries of “go on.”) I will say, also,
that on conference with certain leading, generous and magnanimous
gentlemen who
occupy an opposite position from myself, I have cheerfully consented to
advance
in the debate, and that a representative man upon the other side will
doubtless
follow me, and to him, I am sure, will be as freely and generously
accorded the
same courtesy by my friends as his friends have this moment accorded to
me. (Applause.) Mr. President, I
thought that there was probably no better occasion for an Alabamian to
arise
and address the Democracy of the Mr. Lakeman,
of The President.
What is the purpose of the gentleman?
Does he rise to a question of order? Mr. Lakeman. I
do not. The President.
Then the Chair cannot recognize the
gentleman. (Applause.) Mr Lakeman. I
merely ask the privilege— (Tremendous
shouts of “order.”) The President.
The Chair cannot allow interruptions of
speakers unless at their request, except for the suggestion of
questions of
order. Mr. Yancey. I
would say to the gentleman that, indebted
greatly to the courtesy of this body myself, I am disposed to yield any
courtesy to others that would not consume the time of the Convention,
or
interrupt my own line of argument. Mr. Lakeman. In
order that the Convention may know whether
the gentleman who last spoke (Mr. King of Mr. Yancey. I
had intended, at a proper time, to allude
to the fact, that in my opinion, he did not represent The
Secretary read the
resolution as follows: Resolved,
That the
Democratic party of Missouri hold these cardinal principles on the
subject of
slavery in the Territories: 1st, That Congress has no power to abolish
slavery
in the Territories; 2d, That the Territorial Legislature has no power
to
abolish slavery in any Territory, nor to prohibit the introduction of
slaves
therein, nor any power to exclude slavery therefrom by unfriendly
legislation,
nor any power to destroy or impair the right of property in slaves by
any
legislation whatever. (Loud cheers.) Mr. King,
of Mr. Yancey. I
cannot yield the floor to the delegate from
Mr. Avery,
of Mr. Samuels,
of The President.
The gentleman from Mr. Yancey. Gentlemen
of the Convention, my State has now
to ask of this body the adoption of the resolutions reported by the
majority of
the Committee, because her representatives here believe that they
substantially
conform to the principles enunciated in her platform, which we are
instructed
to insist upon as the only basis upon which Alabama can associate with
the
National Democracy as a party. My State,
gentlemen of the Convention, has been the mark of many a shaft of
calumny and
of misrepresentation, and her delegates on this floor have also been
the
marks—some individuals more than others—of great misrepresentation and
falsehood in relation to their political position.
It has
been charged,
in order to demoralize whatever influence we might be entitled to,
either from
our personal or political characteristics, or as representatives of the
State
of Alabama, that we are disruptionists, disunionists per se; that we
desire to
break up the party in the State of Alabama, to break up the party in
the Union,
and to dissolve the Union itself. Each
and all of these allegations, come from what quarter they may, I
pronounce to
be false. (Applause.) There
is no disunionist, that I know of, in
the delegation from the State of This,
gentlemen, I
trust, is a position that your own elevated natures can, at least,
respect. This, gentlemen, I trust, is a
position to
which you can afford, at least, to accord your sympathies; and amongst
the
members immediately in front of me from the gallant Northwest, I think
that
there are minds and hearts that can respect sentiments that may not
agree with
their own, as regards what is the Constitution of the country, and who
will
accord to us, at least, their sympathy and their respect in standing up
to what
we believe to be a constitutional duty, even at the hazard of
disrupting ties
so long held sacred—the lies that bind us to the Democracy. At all events, we have a duty to perform to
ourselves and to our country. The South
is in a minority, we have been tauntingly told to-day.
In the progress of events and the march of
civilization and emigration, the Northwest has grown up from a mere
infant in
swaddling clothes, at the formation of the Constitution, into the form
and
proportions of a giant people; and owing to their institutions and
demand for
white labor, and the peculiar nature of ours, though advancing side by
side, in
parallel lines—never necessarily in conflict in the great march of
civilization—they have surpassed us greatly in numbers.
We are, therefore, in a numerical minority;
but we do not murmur at this—we cheerfully accept the result—but we as
firmly
claim the right of the minority—and what is that? We
claim the benefit of the Constitution that
was made for the protection of minorities.
In the march of events, feeling conscious of your
numerical power, you
have aggressed upon us. We hold up
between us and your advancing columns of numbers that written
instrument which
your and our fathers made, and by the compact of which, you with your
power were
to respect us and our rights. Our and
your fathers made it that they and their children should forever
observe it;
that upon all questions affecting the rights of the minority, the
majority
should not rely upon their voting numbers, but should look, in
restraint upon
passion, avarice and lust for power, to the written compact, to see in
what the
minority was to be respected, and how it was to be protected, and to
yield an
implicit obedience to that compact. Constitutions
are made solely for the protection of the minorities in government, and
for the
guidance of majorities. You, in your
voting power, are not accustomed to scan its provisions as closely as
we, who,
less in number, find in the instrument the only peaceable solution of
difficulties that otherwise would lead us to defend ourselves with arms. It is but
natural that
the North, conscious of voting strength in Congress, should seek to
wield the
government to its own aggrandizement, and should listen restlessly, and
often
defiantly, to the stern demand of the South that the constitutional
restraints
of delegated power should be rigidly observed; but, at the same time,
you must
remember that it is not only as natural for the South to do this, but
that it
is constitutional; and it is in the compact that you shall forbear. The
simple position of
This
being the state
of the case, will you look back upon the past and see what is already
history
upon this matter? Notice when and how,
at an early day, our institutions were assailed? A
young State was seeking admission into the
Union as an equal with all her sisters, and coming with the same
coronet upon
her brow that Virginia and the Carolinas and Georgia and New York and
New
Jersey wore when the Union was formed—that of African slavery. She was met at the very doors of the Turn
another page in
this history, and read how your petitions flooded the hall that should
be common
to us all, a hall erected in the place where our fathers said that we
should
assemble together, not as enemies but as fellow citizens—read how our
representatives were daily and constantly insulted by the most
insulting
petitions from women, and children, and preachers and men, to take from
us our
clearly defined constitutional rights. Further
still, turn the pages until yon find the question being determined as
regards
our possessions acquired in the Mexican war, in which, gentlemen, it is
but
modestly stating the fact to say that Southern chivalry was equal to
Northern
chivalry,—that Southern blood was poured out in equal quantities with
Northern
blood,—and Southern genius shone as bright upon the battle field as
Northern
genius; and yet, when the battle was o’er, and the dead were buried,
and the
field of battle was cleared of all that was repulsive, and the
glittering spoil
was brought forward, a vast and disproportionate quantity was given to
the
North, and the South was made to take the portion of an almost
portionless son. (Cheers.) Do
you remember how Turn
still another
page in our rapid view of the march of aggression.
Read the How was
this slave
Slate in “embryo” met? It was met by
that distinguished statesman
to whom the
delegate from Missouri has alluded as so worthy of his applause and of
his
approval—it was met at the very threshold of Congress by that
distinguished
statesman, saying that Congress must “intervene” on this question—that
Kansas
should not “regulate her domestic institutions in her own way,” but
that her
Constitution, at the mandate of Congress, must be sent back to the
people to be
ratified (applause)—that the “way” of Kansas must yield to the “way” of
Congress. Sir, is not this the fact? That distinguished statesman, that powerful
man, as I believe him to be, and as I have on more than one occasion
publicly
pronounced him to be, utterly wrong, in my opinion, in his views upon
this
question, but yielding to him most cheerfully the same loyalty to his
convictions of duty that I claim for myself,—he, himself, the author of
that
bill, proposed “intervention by Congress” against the highest sovereign
act of
the young State of Kansas, and through his influence Kansas was made to
take back
her Constitution, and it now sleeps the sleep of death in the archives
of
history. (Loud cheers.) And
what else?
Why, sir, the ink in which is written the history of that
period on this
great question is hardly dry that records the fact that on that issue
this
Northwestern Democracy, which has been so inconsiderately
lauded here to-day by its representative as always standing by the
constitutional
rights of the South, following the fortunes of its great leader, voted
that Congress
should intervene in that matter, and that Kansas should not have a
slave
Constitution without letting the people re-vote upon it.
(Loud cheers ) What else?
Why, sir, the information has barely reached us yet in
official form, but
I believe it is correct, that recently what is called the Wyandotte
Constitution
of Kansas, in other words, the anti-slave Constitution, has been
presented to
Congress, and that the admission of In the
Northern Slates
the Democratic party was overwhelmingly in the ascendant.
Why are they not so now? And
why is the South more unitedly Democratic? The
answer is ready. The anti-slavery
sentiment is dominant at the
North—the slavery sentiment is dominant at the South.
And, gentlemen, let me fell you why, if it is
not presumption in me to tell you, that you have grown weaker and
weaker. It is my belief, from some
observation and
reflection upon this subject, that you are not in the ascendant now,
because
you have tampered with the anti-slavery feeling of that section. I do not mean that you have tampered with it
or yielded to it as a matter of choice. I
do not mean that you are willful traitors to your convictions of duty;
but this
is what I do mean: Fnding the overwhelming preponderance of power in
that
anti-slavery sentiment, believing it to be the common will of your
people you
hesitated, you trembled before its march, and you did not triumph over
the
young Hercules in his cradle, because you made no direct effort to do
so. You acknowledged, gentlemen
of the jury, (shouts of laughter and applause), that
slavery was wrong. Ah!
gentlemen, you are indeed the jury empannelled
to try the great issue. It is the cause
of our common country which is in issue.
But, gentlemen, unlike the advocate who stands at the bar
to speak for
the criminal or innocent accused, I am here unpaid—no feed advocate—I
have no
“axe to grind” here or elsewhere—l am no seeker for office. Years ago resigning to the people all the
trusts they had given me. I have been
unceasingly and diligently their advocate since, and I now remain their
advocate, and though others, officially, can speak for them, I, too can
ask to
be heard as amicus curia. (Applause.)
I was going on to show the only
method in
which you lost your ascendancy. You gave
up the real ground of battle, the key to success, when you
acknowledged, what
was the foundation of the anti-slavery sentiment, that slavery was
wrong. You acknowledged that it could not
exist anywhere
by the law of nature or by the law of God; that it could exist no where
except
by virtue of statutory enactment. In
that you yielded the whole question. In
that you showed the weakness of the soldier who doubts in the midst of
the
conflict on the field of battle. You
simply said, beseechingly, to your anti-slavery countrymen, “slavery
does
exist, but we are not to blame for it.” There
was the weakness of your position. If you
had taken the position that has been
taken by one gallant son of the North, who proclaimed, under the hisses
of
thousands, that slavery was right, that anti-slavery demon, if not
dead, would
long since have been in chains at your feet.
But you have gone down under the admission on your part,
that your
opponents placed their feet upon the strong foundation stone of natural
and
divine right; and I tell you, gentlemen, that you will continue to go
lower and
lower unless you change front and change tactics. The
history of the country shows that I am
right in this matter. They have advanced
from a small band of Abolitionists, who, when I was a schoolboy in one
of the
Northern States, were pelted with rotten eggs whenever they assembled,
even in
the State of Now, what
does all
this indicate to us? Gentlemen, these
are, in part, evidences which, I solemnly assure you, have produced in
the
South—I speak by authority for Alabama, and I speak from assurances
which, I
believe, cannot be mistaken, from other States—a wide-spread and
deep-seated
conviction that the South, with her institutions, is unsafe in the
Union. It is upon that basis, upon these
premises,
that we proceed when we come here; when Alabama comes here, and asks
you to
consider well your position upon this subject; to take a new departure
if it
is, even as you say, a new departure; or if it is but the re-affirmance
of an
old truth, we ask you to re-affirm it in more distinct and unequivocal
language, in order to reassure the Southern people of safety in the
party and
in the Union, and thus save both from disruption. I
pass on with—I will not use so strong an
expression as “contempt”—but I conceive that I cannot afford to notice
any of
the specious declamation and partisan arguments that have been made
here to-day. We come with the constitution
in our hand,
and say to you, if we have been wrong, let us reason together, and see
if we
cannot be set right; if we have been right, let us re-endorse that
right in plainer
and less equivocal language. (Applause.)
And why?
If I had come here, my countrymen, as a disunionist—if I
had come here
as a disruptionist—if I had come here as a factionist—I should come to
you now
with the Alabama
has been
stringent, my countrymen, not in dictating to you, as has been charged,
by the
instructions Alabama has given to her delegation, and which but for the
all-seeing, all-knowing, all-finding-out press, you would never have
heard of,
but to leave no ground of doubt as to her will in the mind of any of
her
delegation; our instructions are merely the will of the State of
Alabama, given
to us for our guidance, and not as a dictation to you.
Gentlemen,
I have thus
shown to you that there is a conviction in our minds that we are not
safe in
the Now,
then, by the
light of those established rules of construction, let us see what is
the
meaning of this branch of the Cincinnati Platform.
First. What was the subject matter upon which it is
based? It was the right of the owner of
slaves to emigrate, and settle, and hold slaves in the Territories of
the Second. What was the cause of the passage of that
resolution? It was that the South was
restless and dissatisfied with the admission of California under
Squatter
Sovereignty principles; dissatisfied with the law forbidding the
internal slave
trade between citizens of slave States and the District of Columbia—and
claimed
perfect freedom to go with slaves into any Territory of the United
States, and
to hold them there until forbid by a constitution constitutionally
formed, and
the admission of the new Srate into the Union.
The South claimed the enactment of that platform for her
own protection. It was not urged by
Northern men for
utterance of Squatter Sovereignty views. No
such power was urged then by anybody, and
the South alone had that platform made, and the cause of it was her
need for
protection, as a political question Third. What were the evils it was designed to
correct? They were the doctrines
maintained by Seward and the Black
Republican party, to
wit: that Congress had the power to abolish slavery in the Territories,
and
that it was its duty to do so. The great
principle at
stake, the great practical evil apprehended, was not only the power by
which
this could be done, but more especially was, could the South be
excluded from
territory held by the general government in trust for the co-equal
States of
the Union. To assure the South on these
points, to allay her apprehensions, and solely on account of and at the
instance
of Southern demand for Congressional interference for purposes of
protection
against the freesoil aggression, was this And now
for the proof. [Mr. Yancey not having time to read
and
elaborate his authorities in support of his general argument, in the
Convention, claims the privilege of presenting them more at large in
this
report of his speech.] Here are the resolutions in that platform on
this
subject. EXTRACT
FROM “And that
we may more
distinctly meet the issue on which a sectional party, subsisting
exclusively on
slavery agitation, now relies to test the fidelity of the people, North
and
South, to the Constitution and the Union: 1. Resolved,
That claiming fellowship with, and desiring the co-operation of all who
regard
the preservation of the Union, under the Constitution, as the paramount
issue—and repudiating all sectional parties and platforms concerning
domestic
slavery, which seek to embroil the States and incite to treason and
armed
resistance to law in the Territories, and whose avowed purposes, if
consummated, must end in civil war and disunion—the American Democracy
recognize and adopt the principles contained in the organic laws
establishing
the Territories of Kansas and Nebraska, as embodying the only sound and
safe
solution of the “slavery question,” upon which the great national idea
of the
people of this whole country can repose in its determined conservatism
of the
Union—non-interference by Congress with
slavery in State
and Territory, or
in the District
of Columbia.
2. That this was the basis of the compromises of
1850—confirmed by both the Democratic and Whig parties in National
Conventions—ratified by the people in the election of 1852—and rightly
applied
to the organization of Territories in 1854.
3. That by the uniform application of this
Democratic
principle to the organization of Territories, and to the admission of
new States,
with or without domestic Slavery, as they may elect, the equal rights
of all the
States will be preserved intact—the original compact of the
Constitution
maintained inviolate—and the perpetuity and expansion of this Union
ensured to
its utmost capacity of embracing in peace and harmony every future
American
State that may be constituted or annexed with a republican form of
government. Resolved, That we
recognize
the right of the people of all the Territories, including Kansas and
Nebraska,
acting through the legally and fairly expressed will of a majority of
actual
residents, and whenever the number of the inhabitants justifies it, to
form a
Constitution with or without domestic slavery, and be admitted into the
Union
on terms of perfect equality with the other States.” The
preamble sets
forth that these resolves were made with a view of “meeting the issue
made by a
sectional party subsisting exclusively on slavery agitation” (which was
clearly
the Freesoil party), and, therefore, it was not made to assert the
dogmas of
any wing of the Democratic party, as it is now here and to-day claimed
to have
been made. The first resolution
expressly asserts that it was drawn for the purpose of repudiating all
sectional parties and platforms (which, undoubtedly, were the Black
Republican and
Abolition parties) concerning domestic slavery, “which seek to embroil
the
States, and incite to treason and armed resistance to law in the
Territories,”
and, therefore, sir, included no part of the Democracy which passed and
upheld
the Act of Kansas, and which was in power in administering the law
there, both
federal and territorial. These parties
had repeatedly charged the Democracy with being propagandists of
slavery, and
that its design was not only to prevent Congress from abolishing or
excluding,
but was also to establish slavery in a Territory by law.
To meet these views, this first resolution
declared that the true aim of the party was “non-interference by
Congress with
slavery in State and Territory, or in the No, sir! Mr. Douglas’ doctrine is at war
with the
rights of Southern citizens, both under the Constitution and under the [Mr. Yancey
here quotes at length the position assumed by Senator Brown, which he
briefly stated in the debate:] ‘“I have
not, in my
own judgment, and I trust I have not, in my action here, yielded the
principle
that the people of the Territories, during their territorial existence,
have
the right to exclude slavery. I have not
intended to yield that point, and I do not mean that my action in
future times
shall be so construed.’ ‘‘Senator
Douglas moved to
postpone
the bill (Nebraska-Kansas) till tomorrow.
“Gen. Cass
asked him to withdraw the motion, and said: ‘The Hon. Senator (Mr. Brown) has
touched on one
of the main questions connected with it, and which has not been touched
before. It is a very grave and a very
important
question. The power of the people of the
Territories to legislate upon their internal concerns, during the
period of these
temporary governments, is most clearly given in this bill, if the
Constitution
permits it.’ “Mr. Badger.
Certainly. “Mr. Cass.
If the Constitution does not permit, they have not got it. “Mr. Badger.
That is clear. “Mr. Cass. Behind
that stands the other question which
must be discussed here; and I, for one, am determined that my
constituents
shall know my views on the point. It is
one on which the Hon. Senator from * * * * * * * * * * * “Mr. Butler. I
wish to save myself. I am perfectly
willing to vote for the clause
(that quoted by me) as modified by the Hon. Senator from Illinois, the
Chairman
of the Committee on Territories (Mr. Douglas),
but with a very clear judgment that, if Congress has not constitutional
competency to legislate either one way or the other—either to introduce
or
prohibit slavery in the Territories, a territorial government has no
derivative
authority to do so from any act which Congress can pass.
“Mr. Brown. Certainly not. “Mr. Butler. I
am perfectly willing to leave this question
under the Constitution. “Mr. Dawson.
That is where it ought to be left.
“Mr. Butler. I
am perfectly willing to leave it under the
Constitution, to be decided by the law tribunals of the country; and
that is
where it ought to be left. If in process
of settlement, the people of these Territories shall be prepared to
assume upon
themselves the attributes of a sovereign State, they can then,
certainly, either
exclude or admit slavery. I presume that
will not be denied by any one. During
their growth, and before they
undertake to become a State, can they assume to exercise a power which
Congress
itself, under the Constitution, cannot confer upon them?
They can have no derivative power on the
subject from an act of ours. “Mr. Cass. That is a matter to be argued.
I differ from the Honorable Senator in toto.
‘I deny
(said he) that
the right to regulate carries along with it the right to destroy. The right to regulate the relation between
master and servant no more entitles the regulating power to destroy
that
relation, than does the power to regulate the relation between husband
and wife
authorize the destruction of that relation.
As well might the Territorial Legislature take a wife from
her husband,
under pretence of regulating their relations, as to take a servant from
his master
under pretence of regulating that relation.
* * * * * If I thought that,
in voting
for the bill as it now stands, I was conceding the right of the people
in the
Territory, during their territorial existence, to exclude slavery. I would withhold my vote.” These
remarks, and the
presence and acquiescence of Mr. Douglas,
show how he and Senator Brown,
at
least understood the bill, or it shows gross misapprehension as to the
meaning
of the bill somewhere. Either view is
sufficient for my purpose It was
only when the
South had obtained an advantage in Kansas, and was about to test the
question
whether another slave State could be admitted into the Union, that this
new
phase of Squatterism appeared as a practical issue under the more
euphonious
name of Popular Sovereignty. Mr. Douglas then, for the first
time, in
practical, tangible form, brought forward this astonishing doctrine,
that the
will of the State Convention—assembled by legal authority, and by the
will of
the people—clothed for the first time with the right to do a sovereign
act—the
formation of the governmental institutions of a new State, must submit
the
result of their labors to a popular vote at the hustings—the
Convention, in
which alone lies any claim to the assumption of power to make the
fundamental
law in our system of republican government, must yield its own judgment
to the
mere masses. The argument was that
the inherent right of the people to all the powers of self-government
had been
invaded, dogmas of the Declaration of Independence were brought forward
to
assert the most revolutionary and incendiary doctrines; dogmas of the
revolution all brought forward for the support of principles
destructive of all
the binding force and security of organic law; and we who are not a
mobocracy:
we, who are not in fact a democracy in form of government; we who have
a
representative government, where laws and constitutions are made by
representative power, ought to guard well our safety lest the wisdom,
judgment
and experience of the past be thrown down and trampled upon in the wild
passionate
struggle of the masses for party or agrarian ascendancy.
(Applause.) Gentlemen
of the
Convention, that venerable, that able, that revered jurist, the
Honorable Chief
Justice of the United States, trembling upon the very verge of the
grave, for
years kept merely alive by the pure spirit of patriotic duty that burns
within
his breast—a spirit that will not permit him to succumb to the gnawings of
disease and to the weaknesses of mortality—which hold
him, as it were, suspended between two worlds, with his spotless ermine
around
him, standing upon the very altar of Justice, has given to us the
utterance of
the Supreme Court of the United States upon this very question. (Applause.) Let the
murmur of the
hustings be stilled—let the voices of individual citizens, no matter
how great
and respected in their appropriate spheres, be hushed, while the law,
as
expounded by the constituted authority of the country, emotionless,
passionless
and just, rolls in its silvery cadence over the entire realm, from the
Atlantic
to the Pacific, and from the ice-bound regions of the North to the
glittering
waters of the Gulf. (Loud cheering.) What says that decision? That
decision tells you, gentlemen, that the
Territorial Legislature has no power to interfere with the rights of
the slave-owner
in the Territory while in a Territorial condition.
(Cheers.) That decision tells you that this
Government is a union of sovereign States; which States are co-equal,
and in
trust for which co-equal States the Government holds the Territories. It tells you that the people of those co-equal
States have a right to go into these Territories,
thus held in trust, with every species of property which is recognized
as
property by the States in which they live, or by the Constitution of
United
States. The venerable magistrate—the
Court concurring with him—decided that it is the duly of this
Government to
afford some government for the Territories which shall be in accordance
with
this trust, with this delegated trust power held for the States and for
the
people of the States. That decision goes
still further; it tells you that if Congress has seen fit, for its own
convenience, and somewhat in accordance with the sympathies and
instincts and
genius of our institutions, to accord a form of government to the
people of the
Territories, it is to be administered precisely as Congress can
administer it,
and to be administered as a trust for the co-equal States of this
Union, and
the citizens of those States who choose to emigrate to those
Territories. That decision goes on to tell
you this: that
as Congress itself is bound to protect the property, which is
recognised as
such, of the citizens of any of the States—as Congress itself, not only
has no power,
but is expressly forbidden to exercise the power to deprive any owner
of his
property in the Territories, therefore, says that venerable, that
passionless
representative of Justice, who yet hovers on the confines of the
grave—therefore, no government formed by that Congress can have any
more power
than the Congress that created it. But, we
are met right
here with this assertion: we are told by the distinguished advocate of
this
doctrine of Popular Sovereignty that this opinion is not a decision of
the
Supreme Court, but merely the opinion of citizen Taney. He
does not tell you, my countrymen, that it
is not the opinion of the great
majority of the Supreme Court bench. Oh
no! but he tells you that it is a matter
that is obiter dicta outside the
jurisdiction of the Court; in other words, extra-judicial—that it is
simply the
opinion of Chief Justice Taney, as an individual, and
not the
decision of the Court, because it was not the subject-matter before the
Court. Now, Mr. Douglas and all others who
make that
assertion and undertake to get rid of the moral, the constitutional,
the
intellectual power of the argument, put themselves directly in conflict
with
the venerable Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States,
and with
the recorded decision of the Court itself—because Chief Justice Taney,
after disposing of the demurrer in that case, undertook to go on and to
decide
the question upon the facts aud the merits of the case; and, said he in
doing
that, we are met with the objection “that anything we may say upon that
part of
the case will be extra-judicial and mere obiter
dicta. This is a manifest mistake,”
&c.; and the Court—not Chief Justice Taney, but the whole Court,
with but two
dissenting voices—decided that it was not obiter
dicta; that it was exactly in point, within the jurisdiction of the
Court,
and that it was the duty of the Court to decide it.
Now then, who shall the Democracy recognize
as authority on this point—a statesman, no matter how brilliant, and
able and
powerful in intellect, in the very meridian of life—animated by an
ardent and
consuming ambition—struggling as no other man has ever done for the
high and
brilliant position of candidate for the Presidency of the United
States, at the
hand of this great party—or that old and venerable jurist who, having
filled
his years with honor, leaves you his last great decision before
stepping from
the high place of earthly power into the grave, to appear before his
Maker, in
whose presence deception is impossible, and earthly position is as dust
in the
balance? (Loud and continued cheering.) Gentlemen,
I am
admonished by the progress of time by the courteous yet warning voice
of the
presiding officer, and by my own feebleness, that I must pass on to
some other
branch of this subject, and close my remarks.
It seems to me as if the subject was but just opening up
before me, but
I trust I have at least opened to you the great vista through which
your own
intellectual vision will enable you to pursue the line of my argument. I do not quote this decision of the Supreme
Court as conclusive authority, or as of binding obligation upon the
State which
I represent, or upon any other State. The
decisions of the courts are binding only upon the parties to the cause
decided,
and are but persuasive of the truth to all others.
The question itself, however, has been before
the Court; the Court has had it before them; the Court say they have
decided
it; the Court decided, against objections, that they had jurisdiction;
the
Court decided that Congress has no power to prohibit slavery in the
Territories, for the single yet comprehensive reason, that the
Constitution
protects slaveholders in a Territory; the Court decided that Congress
cannot
prohibit slavery in the Territories, for the reason that the
Constitution of
the United Stales overrides all the powers that would assail it. Pray tell me by what argument or logic a
Territory, the most inferior form of our government, can have greater
power
than the government that holds these territories in trust—for equal
benefit of
the citizens of each State? (Cheers.) The weakest and most inferior form of all
governments known to the Union is the territorial form of government
given by
Congress, and yet gentlemen tell us that by some peculiar hocus-pocus,
which
they cannot explain and define except by running back to the
Declaration of
Independence and quoting the axiom “that all men are created free and
equal,”
and they can give us no connecting link between that great dogma and
this
theory—they say there is some peculiar process by which, when Congress
gives to
a Territory a government, although Congress did not possess this power
itself,
and could not give it to them, yet it becomes an inherent power on
great
general principles. The Supreme Court of
the United States, in the Dred Scott
case, has met that very position, and Chief Justice Taney said, in
answer to it, “That no reasoning of statesmen, or of jurists”—“none
whatever
upon general principles”—“can enlarge the powers of the Government, or
take
from the citizen the rights they have reserved,” and “that the powers
of the
Government, and the rights of the citizen under it, are positive and
practical
regulations plainly written down.” No matter how beautiful the language
or how
patriotic the sentiment, in which one appeals to these revolutionary
ideas, the
Supreme Court tells you that you will save yourself from faction and
misrule,
and the war of factions, by adhering to the plainly written letter of
the
Constitution; the Government must find its power in the Constitution,
or it is
not conferred. I now
pass from that
branch of the subject. We simply claim
that we, being co-equal with you in the Territories, we having property
which
is as sacred to us as yours is to you, that is recognized as such by
the
constitution of our common country—shall enjoy, unmolested, the rights
to go into
the Territories, and to remain there, and enjoy those rights as
citizens of the
United States, as long as our common government holds those Territories
in
trust for the States of which we are citizens.
That is all. We claim that
there
is no power in any portion of the people who go there to deprive us of
the full
enjoyment of our rights of property, until after having formed a
Constitution,
they are admitted into the But our
friends at the
North say they cannot give up this doctrine with safety.
Why? Why
cannot you give it up? What right of
yours is at stake? What property of
yours is impaired in doing so? What social
relation of yours is endangered by your accepting our views? None whatever. I
have no doubt, gentlemen, that each of you
here enjoys most pleasantly, the hospitalities of this city—even such
hospitalities as you pay for so magnificently (Laughter).
I have no doubt of that, and I have no doubt
that these sable people who wait upon you, who are slaves for life, and
whose
children are born slaves, and who descend to the heirs of their
masters, are
agreeable in their relations to you as an inferior class of beings, who
are
ready to contribute to your comfort, and whom you can command to
contribute to
your comfort. Your relations towards
them would be just the same in the Territories as they are here. The institution does not interfere with you. It does not belong to you to put your hands
on it. You are agressors when you injure
it. You are not brothers when you injure
us, and you are without the excuse of being actuated by the lowest
motives that
can actuate an honest man to do a mean thing—because he is interested
in it. (Loud cheers.) If you desire the
good of your
country—if you desire the welfare of this Union—if you desire, outside
of the Constitution,
to be actuated by love of God, by love of truth, by love of the great
principles of equality—then I would say to you: “Hands off and let us
work our
own row in these Territories.” If you beat us at the end you will be
entitled
to the palm of victory. If we beat you,
we will give you good servants for life and enable you to live
comfortably, and
we will take your poor white man and elevate him from the office of
boot-black,
and from other menial offices which belong to the highest order of
civilization—we
will elevate him to a place amongst the master race and put the negro
race to
do this dirty work which God designed they should do.
(Tremendous cheering.) Mr. Buskirk. I
rise to a question of order. For an hour
and twenty minutes I have listened
to noise in the galleries, and I now move that the galleries be cleared. (Shouts of “no,” “no,” and hisses.) A Delegate.
If there was any noise made during the speech
of the gentleman from The President.
The gentleman from Capt. Rynders.
You will have to stop Mr. Yancey from speaking if you want
to suppress
applause on the floor. (Tremendous
cheering and laughter.) Mr. Yancey.
Gentlemen, it is further said, that this is a judicial
question. It is true it is a judicial
question, but it
is also a political question of the highest, the gravest and the most
significant import. It is a judicial
question between a citizen whose property is taken away from him and
him who
wrongs him. If he chooses to take it to
the Courts of the I turn,
then, from
that aspect of the question; and now, gentlemen, why, why will you not
accord
to the South simple protection? We are
told here, to-day, in answer to this question, by the partisans of
party who
have addressed you, that the fate of our party hangs upon the issue;
but I tell
you, gentlemen, that the fate of our country hangs upon the issue! (Cheers.) I meet
your partisan arguments with the fate
of the party, aye! and of the country itself.
I make no threats. I am not
authorised to do so, and it would be unbecoming in any one to do so. I will state to you, though, my earnest
belief that such is the condition of the public mind at the South, that
it
cannot bear any longer any doubt as regards what is the position of
this party
on this great issue. (Cheers.) We are determined, in no language of threat or
of compulsion, that we must bring up the Democratic party to the great
issue of
loyalty to the Government; we must appeal to the nobler sentiments of
its
members, and ask that their feelings of loyalty to the Government shall
override their principle of mere loyalty to party success.
If need be, we must accept defeat upon great
truths with cheerfulness, rather than rejoice in a victory obtained
upon error
or double dealing. (Tremendous
cheering.) In 1840, what did this
Democracy do, when, I must think, it was a prouder and a purer party
than it is
now? In that great financial issue, when
the people decided against it, and Martin Van Buren was in the chair,
he rose
to the grandeur and the full proportions of a statesman, when in his
message to
the Congress of the I commend
to you, my
countrymen, this bit of history, and the lesson it teaches. Stand firmly on a constitutional basis: go
before your Northern people and appeal to their loyalty to the Go to the
wall upon
this issue if events demand it. Accept
defeat upon it. Let the threatened
thunders roll and the lightning flash through the sky, and let the dark
cloud
be pointed out by you, now resting on the Southern horizon. Let them know that our people are in earnest,
and in accepting defeat upon that issue, my countrymen, you are bound
to rise,
if there is virtue in the Constitution.
But if we adopt of your policy, where are we?
We will then have assented to the great fact
involved in adopting your platform, that the government is a failure so
far as
the protection of the South in the Territories is concerned. We would be estopped forever after from
asserting our principle by your simply pointing to the record, that we
had
assented to the fact that the government could not be administered on a
clear
assertion of our rights. Is that true,
gentlemen of the Northwest? Is it true,
gentlemen of the North and of the whole country, that our government is
a
failure so far as the plain and unequivocal rights of the South are
concerned? If it is a failure, we are not
patriots,
unless we go to work at the very foundation stone of this error and
re-construct this party on a proper basis.
If it is a failure, do not ask us, who are the injured
parties, to
affiliate in building up a party by the acknowledgment on our part that
we dare
not assert our rights in the North for fear of defeat.
If we give you success on such a basis, and
at the end of four years we ask you once more to reconsider, what will
you say? You will say “when the question
was made you
gave us your consent; and do you now ask us to go back and be defeated
once
again, when you have admitted that we could not maintain your
principle?” The
effect of such a
policy will not be merely to give your assent to a failure of the
Government
and of the Democratic party to protect you, but it will be to place
this party
in power, with its myriads of camp followers, to turn adrift all its
discordant
elements on the subject of slavery to affiliate and act with the Black
Republicans
in Congress on propositions hostile to our peace and safety, leaving to
the
South and the party no check upon them—not even the power of indignant
protest. Having no sound and common
article of party
faith by which to prevent this, we shall become a prey to our own
members. The opposite of all this may be
expected from
the adoption of the majority report. That
involves a great constitutional question—an appeal to the ancient
brotherly
love of our people for each other. It
will bring the country face to face with the living issue of the age,
and will
demand its solution at the hands of the people.
It will enable the Democracy to appeal to the loyalty of
all sections to
the Constitution. It will inaugurate a
healthy state of public opinion at the North as well as at the South. It will enable the South to maintain a high
public spirit among its people. It will
bring about once more a community of public feeling, and public
opinion, and
public sentiment running, like a great artery, throughout the body of
the
Democracy, and in time will enable it to save the Government from
becoming a
mere war of factions, or will save the Constitution as the basis of a
new
government. To my
countrymen of
the South I have a few words to say. Be
true to your constitutional duties and rights.
Be true to your own sense of right.
Accept of defeat here, if defeat is to attend the
assertion of the
right, in order that you may secure a permanent victory in whatever
contest you
carry a constitutional banner. Yield nothing of
principle for mere party success—else you will die by the hands of your
associates as surely as by the hand of your avowed enemy. Permit
no party, in lieu of fealty to the
written compact of the Constitution, to put the fiat of its own
allegiance and
fealty upon you, which will forever after be used to prevent your
rising, when
you think the proper time comes, to assert your reserved rights.
Do not demoralize yourselves; do not
demoralize your own people by admitting that you are ready to affiliate
in a
war of factions, merely for the sake of keeping a party in power.
A party, in its noblest sense, is an
organized body that pledges itself to the people to administer the
Government
on a constitutional basis. The people
have no interest in parties, except to have them pledged to administer
the
Government for the protection of their rights.
The leaders of the masses, brilliant men, great statesmen, may, by ever
ignoring the people’s rights, still have a brilliant destiny in the
rewards of
office and the distribution of the eighty millions annually; but when
those
leaders, those statesmen, become untrue to the people, and ask the
people to
vote for a party that ignores their rights, and dares not acknowledge
them, in
order to put and keep them in office, they ought to be strung upon a
political
gallows higher than that ever erected for Haman. (Vehement and
continued applause.) |
Back to Causes of the Civil War (Main page) Back to Other Political Speeches and Correspondence Source:
Speech
of the Hon. William L. Yancey, of Alabama, delivered in the
National Democratic Convention Charleston, April 28th, I860, available
on the Internet Archive, here.
Date added to website: June 15, 2023 |